Choose an application

• Reference Manager
• EndNote
• RefWorks (Direct export to RefWorks)

Will Kymlicka pioneered a theory of liberal multiculturalism with his 1995 book Multicultural Citizenship. In this work, he argues that liberal societies not only can accommodate multicultural rights but indeed they require them in order for individuals to realize the full extent of the freedoms liberalism promises. For all its merits, the trouble with Kymlicka’s theory is that it deals with cultural diversity in only a few forms, namely voluntary immigrants and involuntary national minorities. In this paper, I will ask what sort of multicultural policy should we propose for climate refugees. I will first examine Kymlicka’s concept of a societal culture. In doing so, I will isolate three elements of a societal culture which I assert are the central interests for displaced peoples. These are identity, autonomy, and opportunity interests. I then go on to examine the notion of voluntariness, as the difference of the entitlements of national minorities and immigrants hangs on this distinction. After outlining precisely what is meant by voluntariness, I examine the case of climate refugees and conclude, unsurprisingly, that their migration is involuntary. After this, I address Kymlicka’s objections which he himself outlines to treating refugees like national minorities. These are objections about which country would bear this responsibility, the current dispersion of refugees, and a feasibility argument. I also pull out of Kymlicka’s theory an implied objection which I take to be the prominence of territorial attachment in his theory. I address these objections in turn and isolate the case of climate refugees as precisely those who have the most interest in recreating their societal culture in a new place. I finally go on to propose two ways we may fulfill the entitlements I have posited. We could grant climate refugees some form of local control in their neighborhoods, this would fulfill the identity and autonomy concerns. Alternatively, we could grant climate refugees the right to resettle in a third country, thus meeting the opportunity concerns.